Order Tray | Contact Us | Home | SIG Lists

[aprssig] APRS Open Spec

Steve Dimse steve at dimse.com
Sun Sep 28 16:38:56 UTC 2008


On Sep 28, 2008, at 11:12 AM, Ron McCoy wrote:

> As I said, in part of my post that you elided, "I have no interest in
> stealing anyone's IP."
>
I believed that then and now. I didn't think you were deliberately  
suggesting violating the copyright. I assumed you were simply unaware,  
and sought nothing more that informing you that you needed to secure  
the permission of the copyright holders.

> I don't think anything about my post was provocative.

The first one, no. Nor was there anything provocative in my reply, in  
its entirety:

"Do not forget that the APRS Spec is copyrighted. The only assigned  
right is for non-commercial copying. You would need the APRS Working  
Group's permission for this use."

All of that is true and simply informative. I didn't say you couldn't,  
I said you needed permission, which is absolutely true. Somewhere you  
seem to take this as says all sorts of things that were not in these  
three sentences, like what you wanted to do was "commercial copying",  
and that I was saying you couldn't write your own spec. You launched  
into a tirade, and that is where things took a left turn!

Steve K4HG




More information about the aprssig mailing list